HAUTINORA

JournalResearch

What a Lab Study Found About Peroxide and Bromelain Gels

When researchers study how different ingredients change the color of teeth, they often test experimental gels in a laboratory rather than trying them on people right away. A 2023 study published in the International Journal of Molecular Sciences took a close look at how various substances compare against a standard hydrogen peroxide gel.

The experiment used 60 extracted human teeth that had no cracks or decay. To ensure the teeth would absorb color evenly, the researchers treated the enamel with a 36-percent acid solution for 60 seconds and then stained the teeth in coffee for seven days. They tested six different gel treatments, applying each one for 16 minutes a day over a single week while keeping the teeth stored in artificial saliva between sessions.

When measuring color differences, a standard hydrogen peroxide gel produced the strongest change, going beyond simply removing the coffee stains to alter the underlying natural enamel color. Other gel formulas, including sodium bicarbonate and an ingredient called PAP, also showed measurable stain removal.

By contrast, a gel made with bromelain—an enzyme extracted from pineapple stems—produced a color change that was not statistically significant compared with the study’s placebo gel (a xanthan gel without an active whitening agent). A sodium chlorite gel also failed to reach statistical significance.

The researchers also examined a small sample of teeth using electron microscopes and tested the ingredients on lab-grown cells to check for potential cell toxicity. Under microscopy, the hydrogen peroxide gel showed very mild changes to the enamel surface structure, while bromelain and PAP showed no visible surface changes. The published cell tests covered PAP, sodium bicarbonate, hydrogen peroxide, and bromelain; sodium chlorite was not part of those reported cell results. Of the agents tested, bromelain was the only one classified as non-cytotoxic, while PAP, sodium bicarbonate, and hydrogen peroxide showed toxic effects on the lab-grown cells. Cell toxicity in a petri dish is a basic laboratory measure and does not equate to human safety or predict whether a product will cause tooth sensitivity.

Several important boundaries apply to this research. This was strictly a laboratory test on extracted, acid-etched teeth using gels, so the results cannot be transferred to whitening strips or commercial product formulas used by people. Furthermore, tooth sensitivity was not measured in this study.

Conflict of interest disclosure: Based on the results of the experiments, first author Lena Katharina Müller-Heupt later developed a toothpaste containing bromelain and a tooth-whitening set containing bromelain and PAP, and formed a company, after the experiments were finished and the manuscript was written. The authors state that this did not influence study design, data, writing, or the decision to publish, and the other authors declared no conflict of interest.

A note from HAUTINORA

At HAUTINORA, hydrogen peroxide and bromelain are two of the ingredients we list in our Whitening Complex, together with niacinamide and coconut oil. We read studies like this one to understand how those ingredients have been tested, and where the evidence stops.

This experiment used gels on extracted, coffee-stained teeth, not whitening strips worn in the mouth. The concentrations and the 16-minute protocol are not the same as our formula, which is still under review and has not been published with concentrations. In this study, bromelain’s colour change was not statistically significant compared with the control gel. None of these findings is clinical evidence that HAUTINORA Multi-Active Whitening Strips work in the same way, or at all.

We place a peroxide and an enzyme in the same strip as a formulation choice: two named parts, held in one product. That is not proof that they work better together.

This article is an adaptation of “Effectiveness and Safety of Over-the-Counter Tooth-Whitening Agents Compared to Hydrogen Peroxide In Vitro” by Lena Katharina Müller-Heupt, Nadine Wiesmann-Imilowski, Sebahat Kaya, Sven Schumann, Maximilian Steiger, Monika Bjelopavlovic, James Deschner, Bilal Al-Nawas, and Karl Martin Lehmann (2023), originally published in International Journal of Molecular Sciences, 24(3), 1956, https://doi.org/10.3390/ijms24031956, https://www.mdpi.com/1422-0067/24/3/1956. Licensed under CC BY 4.0. This version has been shortened and rewritten for a general reader; figures and tables are not reproduced. It is not endorsed by the authors or the publisher. Changes: condensed structure, plain-language wording, and a separate HAUTINORA note explaining why the brand reads this research and what the findings cannot prove. The HAUTINORA note is not part of the original article.